It has been speculated many times in the past that former Punjab Chief Minister and senior Bharatiya Janata Party leader Capt Amarinder Singh might go back to his old party. Every time, he denied it strongly and unambiguously.
After Amarinder attended the launch ceremony of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir, the ‘Belonging’, speculations have sparked off once more. This time more seriously. There is a reason for that. After Amarinder came out of the function, he was specifically asked about “ghar-wapsi” (homecoming) to the Congress, to which his answer was not as categorical and unambiguous as it used to be in the past. Yesterday he simply tried to evade the question, saying, “Today it was all about the book launch”.
Optics are too obvious to be missed in politics. Amarinder was the only BJP leader to attend the function. Probably he was the only BJP leader who had been invited to the function. And he made it a point to attend the function. Otherwise, he is not known to keep such commitments. He rarely attends such functions.
The Congress in general and Rahul Gandhi in particular also seemed to make a point. While some sitting Chief Ministers like Revanth Reddy and DK Shivakumar were seated in the second row, Amarinder, despite not holding any official position right now, was made to sit in the front row alongside the Jharkhand Chief Minister Hemant Soren. Another former Congress Chief Minister from Karnataka, Siddaramaiah, was seated in the fourth row.
Above all, when Rahul Gandhi delivered the valedictory address, he specifically made a mention of Amarinder Singh, thus acknowledging his presence. In fact, Amarinder’s was the only name Rahul mentioned during his brief speech. The import of the mention was too difficult to be missed. It was obvious that the mention was deliberate and purposeful.
It is a fact that Amarinder has never felt at home in the BJP, despite enjoying an excellent relationship with the Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Union Home Minister Amit Shah. He has not been able to adjust in the BJP’s Punjab ecosystem. He has on record complained that the party has never bothered to consult him on Punjab despite having 60 years of experience in politics. Compared to that, he has credited Sonia Gandhi with taking him into confidence about all matters concerning Punjab when he was in the Congress.
When Navjot Singh Sidhu’s wife, Navjot Kaur Sidhu, alleged that one needed hundreds of crores of rupees to be a Chief Minister in the Congress, Amarinder defended the party and Gandhi that he had never been confronted with such demands. This was even though Amarinder was removed as Chief Minister at the behest of Navjot Sidhu, who at that time was quite close to Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Gandhi.

An overwhelming majority of Congress leaders and each and every worker in Punjab wishes Amarinder to be back in the party. Barring a few Chief Ministerial aspirants, everyone wants Amarinder to lead the party in 2027 as that can guarantee a certain victory.
Both the party high command as well as the Punjab rank and file have realized that the change of guard in Punjab has not really helped the party. After replacing Amarinder Singh Raja Warring as the PPCC president with Pargat Singh, the party seems to have fragmented further with former Chief Minister Charanjit Singh Channi virtually pronouncing himself to be the Chief Ministerial candidate.
Besides, none of the existing lot of leaders has any appeal in the Malwa region, which sends 69 of the 117 members to the Punjab assembly. Only Capt Amarinder Singh can fill that vacuum, who continues to command a lot of influence across the state, particularly the Malwa region, he himself belongs to.
If Capt Amarinder joins the Congress, it may undoubtedly tilt the balance heavily in favour of the party. And everyone across Punjab and across party lines knows it quite well. That makes his possible homecoming sound quite speculative.
(Views expressed are personal.)











